Comparison of bacteriological culture method and multiplex real-time pcr for detection of mastitis

Abstract

This study includes the evaluation of multiplex real-time PCR (rPCR) kit, which was developed to provide rapid diagnosis of mastitis infections, by working with milk samples of 2 different sources of mastitis and comparing the results with the classical bacteriological culture method (BC). A total of 273 bacteria were isolated in 226 samples (47.88%) out of 472 samples by BC. These were 139 (50.91%) Staphylococcus spp., 61 (22.34%) Streptococcus spp., 15 (5.49%) E. coli , 8 (2.93%) Enterococcus spp., 50 (18.31%) other bacteria. When we look at the multiplex rPCR results; 1052 positive were obtained for the gene regions of 14 different bacteria, 1 yeast, and 1 beta-lactamase gene examined in 472 samples. While no searched gene region was found by rPCR in 78 (16.5%) of the 472 samples studied, at least 1 gene was detected in 394 (83.5%) samples. These 1052 positive samples by rPCR were; 263 (28.43%) Staphylococcus spp. , 51 (5.51%) S. aureus, 57 (6.16%) Enterococcus spp. , 49 (5.29%) C. bovis, 16 (1.73%) S. dysgalactiae, 84 (9.08%) S. agalactiae, 71 (7.67%) S. uberis, 73 (7.89%) E. coli , 14 (1.51%) Prototheca spp. , 39 (4.21%) T. pyogenes/P. indolicus, 5 (0.54%) S. marcescens, 15 (1.62%) K. oxytoca/pneumonia, 117 (12.64%) Mycoplasma spp. , 31 (3.35%) M. bovis, 40 (4.32%) yeast , and 127 samples (26.90%) were beta-lactamase positive. When the antibiotic resistance of the isolates was evaluated, 78 (31.96%) tetracycline, 72 (29.5%) penicillin, and 60 (24.59%) clindamycin resistance were observed predominantly in Gram-positive isolates, while 6 (23.07%) tigecycline, 6 (23.07%) netilmicin, 6 (23.07%) pipercillin resistance was found in gram -negative isolates. While a bacteria and/or yeast gene was found by rPCR in 187 of 246 (76.01%) samples with no bacterial growth, a bacterium was isolated with BC in only 20 (8.84%) samples whose gene region was not found by rPCR. As a result, the multiplex rPCR system used in the diagnosis of mastitis has been found to be quite reliable as it can detect a large number of bacteria in a very short time compared to classical methods. Therefore, we advise the use of rPCR and/or culture for confirmation of clinical signs in mastitis and at routine mastitis surveillance.