Oryantalistlerin fıkhî hadislerin menşei ile ilgili görüşleri ve tenkidi
Loading...
Date
2006
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Uludağ Üniversitesi
Abstract
Yaklaşık iki asrı aşkın bir süredir genelde İslâm, özelde ise hadis hakkında araştırma yapan Oryantalistler, hadisin menşei hakkında Müslüman âlimlerden bütünüyle farklı düşünmektedir. Oryantalistlerin fıkhî hadislerin menşei ile ilgili görüşleri, genel olarak hadisin orijinalitesi konusundaki kanaatlerinin bir uzantısıdır. Bu araştırmada önce Oryantalistlerin hadisin menşei hakkındaki genel yaklaşımları üzerinde durulacak, sonra özellikle fıkhî/hukukî hadislerin ortaya çıkışı ile ilgili görüşleri ele alınacaktır. Daha sonra da bütün bu görüşler değerlendirilmeye çalışılacaktır. Çalışmada, genel itibariyle Oryantalistlerin de zaman zaman yaptığı gibi, Müslüman âlimler tarafından yazılmış eserlerde yer alan H.I ve II. asır ile ilgili bilgi ve beyânlar temel alınacaktır.
A hadith narrator narrates a hadith after than analyses and comments it in his opinion. One of facts that may impress the narrator’s analyses and comments efforts, is his theological thought, denominationalism and to be member of a denomination that comes into view from the ends of the I. century. With its this property, the membership of denomination is one of merits that shapes to personal and social life. But, at least in some part of society, the membership thought is transformed into extreme attachment that causes to be perceived the denomination leader’s opinion as absolute and unique true. This fact may play a part sometimes in understanding and comment of hadiths and verses. In this article, we investigated, in exemplifity of three hadiths, the effect of theological thought and denominationalism on hadiths.
A hadith narrator narrates a hadith after than analyses and comments it in his opinion. One of facts that may impress the narrator’s analyses and comments efforts, is his theological thought, denominationalism and to be member of a denomination that comes into view from the ends of the I. century. With its this property, the membership of denomination is one of merits that shapes to personal and social life. But, at least in some part of society, the membership thought is transformed into extreme attachment that causes to be perceived the denomination leader’s opinion as absolute and unique true. This fact may play a part sometimes in understanding and comment of hadiths and verses. In this article, we investigated, in exemplifity of three hadiths, the effect of theological thought and denominationalism on hadiths.
Description
Atıf alanında belirtilen sayfa numaraları derginin basılı halinden alınmıştır.
Keywords
Mezhepleşme, Hadis rivayeti, Anlama, Yorumlama, Denomination, Hadith narration, Understanding, Comment
Citation
Kahraman, H. (2006). "Oryantalistlerin fıkhî hadislerin menşei ile ilgili görüşleri ve tenkidi". Uludağ Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi, 15(2), 45-76.